METHODOLOGY / PROPOSED V0.1
A grade must show its work.
Transparent inputs. Independent review. A visible path to correction.
The scoring model
Each input scores all five dimensions from 0–100. The dimensions are weighted within each input, then the three inputs are averaged at exactly one-third each (displayed as 33.3%).
Accessibility is evaluated within every dimension. Scores are calculated before rounding; letter thresholds use the unrounded score.
A+ ≥97 · A ≥93 · A− ≥90 · B+ ≥87 · B ≥83 · B− ≥80 · C+ ≥77 · C ≥73 · C− ≥70 · D ≥60 · F <60.
Insufficient evidence = Not rated
Production publication requires all three inputs, a complete evidence trail and adequate coverage. Missing inputs are not zeroes and are not silently reweighted.
Independence is the product.
Membership and service fees pay for work. They do not buy score points, editorial silence, removal of substantiated records, or endorsement.
Community experience
Feedback is moderated and checked for provenance, duplicate submissions and conflicts. A review is a signal, not a finding. Famewall is a display layer; confidential evidence requires a separate secure intake.
Right of reply & correction
Every organization can respond and appeal factual errors without joining. Corrections are versioned publicly. Serious disputes receive a second reviewer.
Earn-back through outcomes
A verified corrective action updates relevant indicators. It does not erase the incident. Repeat incidents trigger review of sustainability and governance.
Material repair
Track committed, disbursed and independently verified amounts separately. Repair reaches affected people; Chamber fees are excluded.